When specifying carbon steel flanges for pressure piping systems, engineers frequently encounter three common material grades: P250GH, Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8, Dan ASTM A105. Although these materials have similar applications and comparable mechanical properties, they are governed by different standards and are intended for different manufacturing processes and regional markets.
- P250GH is primarily a European pressure vessel steel.
- Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 is a European forging steel widely used for EN 1092-1 forged flanges.
- ASTM A105 is the most common forged carbon steel flange material in North America and international ASME piping systems.
Selecting the correct material requires understanding the applicable standards, product forms, certification requirements, and project specifications.
Quick Comparison
| Milik | P250GH | Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 | ASTM A105 |
| Material Number | 1.046 | 1.046 | No EN Material No. |
| Standar | ID 10028-2 | ID 10222-2 | ASTM A105 / ASME SA105 |
| Product Form | Plate, Pipe, Pressure Equipment | Tempa | Tempa |
| Typical Flange Standard | ID 1092-1 | ID 1092-1 | ASME B16.5 / B16.47 |
| Perlakuan Panas | Normalized / NR | Dinormalkan | As-forged or Normalized (A105N) |
| Primary Market | Eropa | Eropa | North America & International |
| PED Projects | Ya | Ya | Yes (with certification) |
Standar yang Berlaku
| Bahan | Primary Standard | Typical Products |
| P250GH | ID 10028-2 | Pressure vessel plates, piping components |
| Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 | ID 10222-2 | Forged flanges, valve bodies, forged rings |
| ASTM A105 | ASTM A105 / ASME SA105 | Forged flanges, fittings, valve components |
Chemical Composition Comparison
| Elemen | P250GH | Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 | ASTM A105 |
| Karbon (C) | ≤0.20% | ≤0.22% | ≤0,35% |
| Silikon (Si) | ≤0.40% | ≤0.40% | 0.10–0.35% |
| Mangan (Mn) | 0.60–1.70% | 0.60–1.50% | 0.60–1.05% |
| Fosfor (P) | ≤0.025% | ≤0.025% | ≤0,035% |
| Belerang (S) | ≤0,015% | ≤0,020% | ≤0.040% |
Analysis
- P250GH has tighter sulfur and phosphorus limits, making it well suited for pressure equipment.
- Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 has a composition very similar to P250GH because both share Material No. 1.0460.
- ASTM A105 allows a higher maximum carbon content, which can provide higher strength but may require greater attention to weldability and heat treatment depending on the application.
Perbandingan Sifat Mekanik
| Milik | P250GH | Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 | ASTM A105 |
| Kekuatan Hasil | ≥250 MPa | ≥250 MPa | ≥250 MPa |
| Kekuatan Tarik | 410–530 MPa | 410–530 MPa | 485–655 MPa |
| Pemanjangan | ≥22% | ≥22% | ≥22% |
Analysis
All three materials satisfy the requirements for pressure-retaining components. ASTM A105 generally has a higher tensile strength range, while P250GH and C22.8 are optimized for European pressure equipment applications.
Perlakuan Panas
| Bahan | Typical Heat Treatment |
| P250GH | Normalized (N) / Normalized Rolled (NR) |
| Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 | Dinormalkan |
| ASTM A105 | As-forged or Normalized (A105N) |
Aplikasi Umum
P250GH
- Pressure vessels
- Ketel Uap
- Steam piping
- Heat exchangers
- EN 1092-1 fabricated components
Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8
- EN 1092-1 forged flanges
- Valve bodies
- Forged rings
- Pressure equipment forgings
ASTM A105
- ASME B16.5 flanges
- ASME B16.47 flanges
- Forged fittings
- Valve components
- Oil & Gas piping
Which Material Is Better for Flanges?
| Aplikasi | Recommended Material |
| EN 1092-1 Forged Flanges | Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 |
| European Pressure Equipment | P250GH |
| ASME B16.5 Flanges | ASTM A105 / A105N |
| North American Projects | ASTM A105 |
| German EPC Projects | Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 |
| European Pressure Vessel Fabrication | P250GH |
Keuntungan
P250GH
- Kemampuan las yang sangat baik
- Stable normalized properties
- Widely accepted for pressure equipment
- PED compliant
Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8
- Excellent forging performance
- Preferred for forged flanges
- Excellent machinability
- Common in German projects
ASTM A105
- Global availability
- Standard material for ASME flanges
- Cost-effective
- Excellent forging characteristics
- Broad acceptance in Oil & Gas projects
Kesimpulan
Although P250GH, Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8, Dan ASTM A105 are often considered similar, they are intended for different standards and manufacturing routes.
- Choose P250GH for European pressure equipment and fabricated components.
- Choose Bahasa Indonesia: C22.8 for ID 1092-1 forged flanges and forgings.
- Choose ASTM A105 for ASME B16.5/B16.47 flanges and North American piping systems.
Material selection should always be based on the project specification, applicable design code, operating conditions, and certification requirements.
FAQs
No. They share the same material number (1.0460) but are defined under different European product standards. P250GH is primarily a pressure vessel steel grade, while C22.8 is a forging grade.
C22.8 and ASTM A105 are widely regarded as approximate equivalents for forged pressure components, but they are produced under different standards and should not be substituted without engineering approval.
C22.8 is generally the preferred forging material for EN 1092-1 forged flanges because it is specifically covered by the European forging standard.
Yes. ASTM A105 is widely accepted in international projects. However, many European EPC projects specifically require EN-designated materials such as P250GH or C22.8 together with PED and EN 10204 certification.
Full-service supplier of EN 1092-1 flanges for all your requirements
SSM offers significant product advantages in the manufacture of EN-1092-1 flanges. Whether it’s quality or price – we will meet your requirements.
European Standard Carbon Steel Flanges for Industrial Piping Systems
SSMALLOYS manufactures and supplies EN 1092-1 carbon steel flanges for the European, Middle Eastern, and global industrial markets. Our products are available in P250GH, C22.8, P235GH, P355NL1, and other pressure vessel steel grades, meeting the requirements of ID 1092-1, PED 2014/68/EU, Dan EN 10204 certification.
From standard PN16 flanges to high-pressure PN100 forged flanges, we provide reliable flange solutions for oil & gas, petrochemical, power generation, water treatment, shipbuilding, and industrial piping systems.
Looking for a Reliable EN 1092-1 Carbon Steel Flange Supplier?
SSMALLOYS provides high-quality forged carbon steel flanges with fast delivery, competitive pricing, and complete certification.
Contact our engineering sales team today for a quotation or technical support.
ID 
EN 
DE 
RU 
FA 
ES 
FR 
NL