Hastelloy C-22 vs Hastelloy C-276

Daftar isi

Hastelloy C22 (UNS N06022) and Hastelloy C276 (UNS N10276) are two of the most widely used nickel-chromium-molybdenum alloys for highly corrosive environments. Both alloys offer exceptional resistance to pitting, crevice corrosion, stress corrosion cracking, and a wide range of aggressive chemicals.

Although they appear similar, their chemical composition, corrosion behavior, mechanical properties, and application focus differ significantly. Selecting the correct alloy can improve equipment reliability, extend service life, and reduce lifecycle costs.

This guide compares Hastelloy C22 and Hastelloy C276 in terms of chemical composition, physical properties, mechanical performance, corrosion resistance, service temperature, applications, and cost.

Quick Comparison

MilikPelindung C22Pelindung C276
Nomor UNSNomor 06022Nomor 10276
ASTM StandardsASTM B574, B575, B619, B622, B366ASTM B564, B575, B619, B622, B366
kromium20–22.5%14.5–16.5%
Molibdenum12.5–14.5%15–17%
Serigala2.5–3.5%3–4.5%
Oxidizing Media★★★★★★★★★☆
Reducing Media★★★★☆★★★★★
Minyak & Gas★★★★☆★★★★★
Pengolahan Kimia★★★★★★★★★★

Chemical Composition Comparison

ElemenPelindung C22Pelindung C276
Nikel (Ni)KeseimbanganKeseimbangan
Kromium (Cr)20.0–22.5%14.5–16.5%
Molibdenum (Mo)12.5–14.5%15.0–17.0%
Wolfram (W)2.5–3.5%3.0–4.5%
Besi (Fe)2–6%4–7%
Kobalt (Co)≤2,5%≤2,5%
Mangan (Mn)≤0,5%≤1,0%
Silikon (Si)≤0,08%≤0,08%
Karbon (C)≤0,015%≤0.01%
Vanadium (V)≤0,35%≤0,35%
Fosfor (P)≤0.02%≤0.04%
Belerang (S)≤0.02%≤0,03%

Composition Analysis

Pelindung C22

  • Higher chromium content
  • Better oxidation resistance
  • Excellent resistance to wet chlorine and ferric chloride

Pelindung C276

  • Higher molybdenum and tungsten
  • Superior reducing acid resistance
  • Outstanding localized corrosion resistance

Perbandingan Sifat Fisik

MilikC22C276
Kepadatan8,69 gram/cm³8,89 gram/cm³
Kisaran Peleburan1357–1400°C1325–1370°C
Panas Spesifik410 J/kg·K427 J/kg.K
Konduktivitas Termal11.1 W/m·K10.2 W/m·K
Resistivitas Listrik1.14 μΩ·m1.30 μΩ·m
Modulus Elastisitas206 GPa205 GPa
Thermal Expansion (20–100°C)12.4 μm/m·°C11.2 μm/m·°C

Physical Property Highlights

  • C276 is slightly denser because of its higher Mo and W content.
  • C22 has marginally better thermal conductivity.
  • Both alloys maintain dimensional stability at elevated temperatures.

Perbandingan Sifat Mekanik

MilikPelindung C22Pelindung C276
Kekuatan Tarik≥690 MPa≥690 MPa
Kekuatan Hasil (0,2%)≥310 MPa≥283 MPa
Pemanjangan≥45%≥40%
Kekerasan≤100 HRB≤100 HRB

Mechanical Performance

Both alloys provide:

  • Excellent toughness
  • High ductility
  • Outstanding weldability
  • Excellent fatigue resistance

C22 generally exhibits a slightly higher yield strength than C276.

Maximum Service Temperature Comparison

MilikPelindung C22Pelindung C276
Maximum Continuous Service Temperature≈1040°C (1900°F)≈1090°C (2000°F)
Short-Term Oxidation ResistanceBagus sekaliBagus sekali
Thermal StabilityBagus sekaliBagus sekali

Temperature Analysis

Both alloys retain good mechanical properties at elevated temperatures. However:

  • Pelindung C276 is generally preferred for higher-temperature reducing environments because of its higher molybdenum and tungsten content.
  • Pelindung C22 performs exceptionally well in oxidizing atmospheres and mixed chemical environments.

Catatan: The actual maximum service temperature depends on the operating medium, mechanical load, oxidation conditions, and design code requirements. Continuous service limits should always be verified for the specific application.

 

Corrosion Resistance Comparison

LingkunganC22C276
Hydrochloric Acid★★★★☆★★★★★
Asam sulfat★★★★☆★★★★★
Nitric Acid★★★★★★★★★☆
Ferric Chloride★★★★★★★★★☆
Wet Chlorine★★★★★★★★★☆
Mixed Acids★★★★★★★★★★
Seawater★★★★★★★★★★
Korosi PittingBagus sekaliBagus sekali
Korosi CelahBagus sekaliBagus sekali
Retak Korosi TeganganBagus sekaliBagus sekali

Kemampuan Las

Both Hastelloy C22 and C276 have excellent weldability using GTAW, GMAW, SMAW, and PAW welding processes.

Post-weld heat treatment is generally not required when proper filler metals and welding procedures are used.

Aplikasi Umum

Pelindung C22

  • Chemical reactors
  • Pharmaceutical equipment
  • Bleaching systems
  • Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD)
  • Waste treatment
  • Chlorination equipment

Pelindung C276

  • Minyak & Gas
  • Offshore platforms
  • Petrochemical plants
  • Pressure vessels
  • Heat exchangers
  • Sour service piping
  • Acid processing equipment
Industri Pengolahan Kimia

Cost Comparison

BarangPelindung C22Pelindung C276
Raw Material CostLebih tinggiLebih rendah
Manufacturing CostSlightly HigherLebih rendah
Market AvailabilitySedangBagus sekali
Global DemandSedangSangat Tinggi
Typical Lead TimeLongerShorter

Cost Analysis

Although both alloys belong to the premium nickel alloy family, Hastelloy C22 generally costs 5–15% more than Hastelloy C276, depending on market prices for nickel, chromium, molybdenum, and tungsten.

Reasons include:

  • Higher chromium content
  • Lower global production volume
  • More specialized applications
  • Smaller market demand

Hastelloy C276 benefits from larger production volumes and broader industrial use, making it easier to source and often more cost-effective.

Which Alloy Should You Choose?

AplikasiRecommended Alloy
Hydrochloric Acid⭐ C276
Asam sulfat⭐ C276
Nitric Acid⭐ C22
Wet Chlorine⭐ C22
Ferric Chloride⭐ C22
Mixed Acids⭐ C22
Minyak & Gas⭐ C276
Offshore⭐ C276
Pengolahan KimiaBoth

Procurement Recommendation

Choose Pelindung C22 when:

  • Excellent resistance to oxidizing chemicals is required.
  • The service involves wet chlorine, ferric chloride, or mixed acid environments.
  • Maximum corrosion resistance is the primary concern.

Choose Pelindung C276 when:

  • The process involves strong reducing acids such as hydrochloric or sulfuric acid.
  • The application is in oil & gas, offshore, or petrochemical industries.
  • Lower procurement cost and wider availability are important.

Available Product Forms

SSMALLOYS manufactures and supplies:

  • Pelat & Lembaran
  • Pipes & Tubes
  • Sambungan Pipa
  • Flensa
  • Perlengkapan Tempa
  • Bars & Rods
  • Tempa
  • Pengencang

Manufactured according to:

  • ASTM B564
  • ASTM B575
  • ASTM B619
  • ASTM B622
  • ASTM B366
  • ASME SB564
  • ASME SB366
  • ASME SB622
Hastelloy C-22 vs Hastelloy C-276

FAQs About Hastelloy C-22 vs Hastelloy C-276

Not necessarily. C22 performs better in oxidizing environments, while C276 offers superior resistance in reducing acids and remains the preferred choice for many oil & gas applications.

In some cases, yes. However, alloy selection should be based on the service medium, temperature, pressure, corrosion mechanism, and applicable design standards.

Hastelloy C22 is typically 5–15% more expensive than Hastelloy C276 because of its higher chromium content and lower production volume.

Both alloys provide excellent weldability and generally do not require post-weld heat treatment.

Hastelloy C276 is the most widely used nickel alloy in chemical processing, oil & gas, offshore, and power generation due to its versatility and availability.

Sumber Terkait
Perbarui preferensi cookie
id_IDID
Gulir ke Atas